You cannot teach the Holocaust to
by Stephen D. Smith, Times of Israel, Nov. 27, 2013
Mohammed Dajani Daoudi teaches about the Holocaust to Palestinians although he insists it is impossible to do so.
“In my class is a girl who was recently released from an Israeli jail. When I raised the subject of the Holocaust in class all she could say was, ‘I am still dealing with my own traumatic experiences, I am nowhere near ready to learn about this!’”
The political science professor who heads the American Studies department at Al-Quds University, is unflustered by such pushback.
“I do not start by teaching about the Holocaust, because it is not a Holocaust course. It cannot be because no one would attend! I teach a program on creative and critical thinking. That’s how we eventually get to talk about the Holocaust.”
Dajani encourages students to think through difficult issues and find creative solutions using their critical skills. The eight-part program introduces the Holocaust at around Part 4.
Introducing the subject creates tension in the classroom.
“They push back hard wanting to know why I am talking about the Holocaust and not the Nakbar.”
He reminds them it is a creative-thinking class that encourages them to have open minds to challenging issues. Instead of leaving, the students become engaged.
Israeli professor of the Holocaust Yehuda Bauer, speaking at the USC Shoah Foundation, recently looked at the same issue from a pedagogical perspective.
“If you want to teach about the Holocaust to Palestinians – as difficult as that might be – you have to start with the Nakba.”
Bauer, who for over 50 years has anchored the world of Holocaust scholarship, was not born yesterday.
“When I teach African-Americans, I begin with slavery. When I talk to Rwandans, I begin with discussing the genocide in that country. You have to start with the perspective of the class. That is just good teaching.”
With many critical issues between Israel and the Palestinians, one may contemplate that discussing the Holocaust in East Jerusalem or Ramallah will only serve to throw fat on the fire. Dajani does not think so.
“When students say to me, ‘Why are you talking about the Holocaust, when Israelis don’t learn about the Nakba?’ I tell them, ‘It is your responsibility to know about your world and what happened to the Jews whether or not they take responsibility to understand about the Nakba, because truth is truth, and there is never a downside to understanding the truth.’”
In fact, Dajani bases his approach to teaching about the Holocaust on a series of values.
“It is a sign of respect for the truth. When truth is denied or ignored, it destroys those values one cherishes. It is the right thing to do. Being criticized for doing it does not mean not to do it. Holocaust denial and distortion is historically wrong and morally unacceptable; Lessons of the past help avoid their recurrence in the future. Intellectual knowledge and learning is encouraged in the Holy Quran. Without knowing about evil, we cannot understand the meaning of good. To make this world a better place we need to show empathy and compassion for the suffering of others.”
It seems almost naive to think that this laundry list of ideals proclaimed in the face of extremist ideologies will ever get any traction.
“What I need is a beautiful space with great resources in our library so that students choose to sit inside learning during their lunchbreak, rather than outside listening to extremist recruiters on their megaphones!”
As Dajani pleads on behalf of silence, knowledge and learning at Al Quds University, I commit the USC Shoah Foundation to one day provide some of those resources by way of testimony subtitled in Arabic. That’s where the Aladdin Project comes in.
The Paris-based translation group believes resources about the Holocaust in local languages are the key to opening dialogue. According to Director Abe Radkin, Aladdin has translated scores of books, films and documentaries to make them available to courageous educators like Dajani, right across the Muslim world.
I try to figure whether it will be a good use of our resources to engage in the Muslim world. After all, translating and subtitling may be a good thing in itself, but if they are not watched, or there are no programs, or the programs yield no tangible results, then maybe we will be wasting our time taking the Shoah Foundation’s Visual History Archive into the Muslim world.
I push Mohammed Dajani on whether his students take interest beyond that first lesson.
“It is not easy, but it is necessary. All I can tell you is that the latest group of Palestinians I knew I could not teach the Holocaust to are preparing to visit Auschwitz next year.”